History is not a pre-determined path but the outcome of complex interactions that, at every point in time, can open up many paths and narratives. Writer, economist, environmentalist and urban theorist SANJEEV SANYAl speaks to Saritha Saraswathy Balan about his new book
Forgotten people mostly find no place in history. Those who write about the past, sometimes, tend to prefix their focus and end up in personifying the existing heroes and endorsing prevailing views.
Sanjeev Sanyal, a multi-faceted Indian, to be precise a Bengali, who lives in Singapore, prefers to write history by filtering it from biases and prejudices. And so is his latest book The Ocean of Churn. Sanjeev unravels the history of the coastal areas on the Indian ocean in the book, published recently by Penguin. So the book also deals with the history of lands surrounded by the Indian OceanIJ “Yes that is why I say that Ocean of Churn is not an account of ocean history but on coastal history”, he clarifies.
One of the things the book attempts to show is the extent to which history looks different when viewed from the perspective of coastlines rather than the inlands. This shift in approach changes our perceptions of both events and individuals. “For example, Mauryan emperor Ashoka is often portrayed in conventional history as a great monarch and a pacifist. However, when see from the perspective of the coastal state of Odisha, he appears much less benign. The same can be said of Tipu Sultan, the ruler of Mysore in the 18 the century, who is often lionised in India for his opposition to British colonial expansion. When seen from the perspective of the Kerala coast, he looks like a ruthless marauder,” says the author.
A difficult task for sure, especially since he attempted to overcome biases that sometimes came in the way to present history as it is. “True it was difficult to collect the evidence. But since being open made things to come my way,” says the author. “The influence of Indian civilisation on South East Asia is obvious to anyone who has travelled around the region and is increasingly well documented. However, the impact that South East Asia had on cultural and historic events in India is less appreciated. Evidence suggests that the influence flowed both ways. One example is the famous university of Nalanda in Bihar that attracted students from around the Indian Ocean rim as well as from China and Central Asia. Few people realise that the university was partly funded by the Sri Vijaya kings of Sumatra,” he adds.
Sanyal connects the missing dots of history that some of his predecessors in the job failed to take note of. The author credits the feat to his non-linear approach towards history. “History is not a linear process. It is also happening in front of our eyes. We are also part of history. Radical changes are going on in front of us like the drying up of the Saraswati river and massive migration. History is not full if we don’t take all this in to account. It is a rigorous journey, a churning process and hence I named the book The Ocean of Churn.”
The book is a brief and eclectic history of the Indian ocean rim and many forces — political, economical, socio-cultural, technological and natural- that have shaped the world we see around us. “It is an attempt to give a feel of a colourful and ever changing Indian Ocean world and its impact on human history”, the author says.
Sanyal views the world as a “complex adaptive system,” a chaotic place where the flow of events is influenced by the constant and often unpredictable interactions between a host of factors. He believes that these factors could be anything from, arguably, the Hindu religion to the English language. It is this non-linear, discerning and insightful approach that differentiates his work from many of his counterparts.