Sports

Sandpapergate revelations reopen old wounds

Shakya Mitra

Eight years after Sandpapergate rocked Australian cricket, Usman Khawaja’s book, “Sabr”, has brought the controversy back into the spotlight. What was perhaps an episode that several members of the Australian dressing room would have preferred to leave in the past is once again being discussed, with Khawaja questioning whether the three players who were punished were the only ones who should have been held accountable.

There is little doubt about the gravity of what happened during Australia’s 2017-18 tour of South Africa. In the third Test at Cape Town, Cameron Bancroft was caught on television attempting to alter the condition of the ball using sandpaper before concealing the object in his trousers. Captain Steve Smith subsequently admitted that the plan had been discussed within a small leadership group, while Cricket Australia’s investigation identified vice-captain David Warner as the principal architect. Smith and Warner received 12-month suspensions, while Bancroft was banned for nine months.

Khawaja’s contention that the episode was a collective failure, despite only three players being punished, is what makes his account particularly significant. Having been part of that dressing room, his perspective cannot simply be dismissed. However, there is also a distinction between questioning the culture within a team and suggesting that other players were directly involved. Nevertheless, the question of how much the wider team knew, and whether the original investigation captured the full picture, is one that continues to linger.

The timing of these revelations is particularly interesting because Australian cricket has not stood still since Sandpapergate. Smith and Warner returned to international cricket in 2019 and continued sharing a dressing room with several of the same teammates for many years. Though never given the full-time role, Smith has occasionally been a stand-in captain, while Warner remained an integral part of the side until his international retirement in 2024. Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, who were part of the Australian setup during that period, have also continued to be central figures in the team. These are not relationships that ended with the scandal. They have evolved over several years of international cricket, major victories and shared dressing-room experiences.

This is where Khawaja’s book could have an impact beyond the immediate debate surrounding Sandpapergate. If some of the players who were part of that team feel that their reputations are being questioned again, it could reopen disagreements that were never entirely resolved. For those who served bans, the issue may be about whether they were made scapegoats for a wider cultural failure.

It is also worth remembering the personal cost of the scandal. Smith was arguably the world’s best Test batter at the time and lost an entire year of international cricket in what was the prime of his career. As the team’s captain, his reputation was greatly tarnished. Warner brought up the personal difficulties he and his wife Candice endured during the period during a recent commentary stint which included a miscarriage.

Cummins’s rise to the Australian captaincy is another aspect that should be viewed independently of the scandal. He was still a young and relatively inexperienced player at the time having overcome some tough injuries, and it would be simplistic to suggest he was merely a beneficiary of Sandpapergate. It wasn’t until November 2021 that he was named Test captain after Tim Paine resigned and a year later took over the ODI captaincy from Aaron Finch. Having won the World Test Championship and ODI World Cup under his captaincy in 2023, he has proven himself to be a successful captain.

There is, however, a broader question about accountability that Khawaja’s book brings into focus. Ball tampering is hardly new to cricket, but the Cape Town episode was particularly damaging because it involved the Australian captain and vice-captain and exposed a culture in which the desire to win appeared to have overtaken the spirit of the game. Cricket Australia’s investigation may have provided an official conclusion, but that does not necessarily mean every individual who was part of the dressing room has the same understanding of what happened.

Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg has indicated that there is no intention of reopening the investigation. Institutionally, that may be the sensible course. But an investigation and the personal relationships affected by its findings are two different matters. Khawaja’s book cannot change the punishments handed out in 2018, nor can it establish guilt where evidence is lacking. What it can do is bring back uncomfortable questions among players who have spent eight years trying to put the episode behind them.

The author is a sports management consultant; Views presented are personal.