Opinion

When marriage unravels, the self begins to emerge

Sanjay Kumar

In Vedic astrology, the first house represents the self: identity and the way an individual seeks to come to terms with, encounters, and, by implication, seeks to understand the world. The First House by Avni Doshi (Fourth Estate) has multiple references to astrology. When the unnamed narrator's life spirals into a tailspin after her husband reads out the riot act of estrangement and divorce to her after thirteen years of marriage, and she is not able to rationalise why and how things happened the way they happened, astrology- as a system of explanations- seems to be a substitute for the inadequacy of reason. Besides, two other metaphors- the Roman Goddess Diana and Cicadas- frequently appear in the novel. 

Diana represents a form of womanhood that is not beholden to marriage, motherhood or male approval. She is a huntress, and that speaks of a world that transcends the constraints of respectable social behaviour. A counterpoint to conventional expectations of femininity.  Cicadas remain underground for years before they come out, shed the exoskeleton, transform themselves, and lead an ephemeral but vigorous existence before dying.  Diana speaks of independence, agency and will. Cicadas speak of the possibility of transformation. A matrimony of thirteen years- when it begins to unravel- offers limited choices: to accept it as the working of an inscrutable fate or to redeem oneself using one's own agency. Caught between a husband gone rogue and a natal family that is unpredictable, unempathetic and imposing, she will redeem herself in her own ways and on defiant terms.

Indictment of the institution of Marriage

Doshi employs unsentimental and unsparing prose to develop the novel around what marriage as a regimented system involving impossible expectations entails and how this cultural construct is at odds with identity, individuality and nature. Culture could be deployed to tame school and nature, but nature is too elemental, too formidable and too wild to be kept on a leash for too long. Doshi dissects these phenomena in a way that has deep sociological and psychological insights. The narrative shifts frequently between the present and the past, between painful realism and dreams.  The abruptness of marital rupture makes her grope for reasons that could have triggered the rupture. As an institution, marriage comes up for stinging and scathing criticism. Monogamy as a cultural idea that demands taming of natural instincts. Mundanity of marriage in which daily, boring chores pip the promised or expected love to the post. Inadequacy of marital relationship that 'could only support one whole person at a time. For the other person, marriage was a Procrustean bed.' Monogamy as the precondition for infidelity. Incompatibility of love and marriage- love as protean, marriage as procrustean. Marriage amounting to the erasure of individuality and identity. Marriage demanding too much from two individuals in terms of the attempted merger of two identities into one. The unnamed narrator goes back in time to pin down the reasons for the predicament she, along with her two daughters, finds herself pitted against.

All that she would get are illusory inklings, slippery hunches, inadequate rationalisations and shifting sands. She sounds bitter and cynical when she seeks to rationalise, "It occurred to me that we had both objectified each other. I had wanted a life made of stone; he had wanted a statue instead of a woman and was startled when I came to life."

Family and its Fragility

Salman Rushdie in 'Joseph Anton' makes a stinging remark about the pathology of family as an institution. He quotes Edmund Leach, the British anthropologist, "Far from being the basis of the good society, the family, with its narrow privacy and tawdry secrets, is the source of all our discontents." Rushdie argues that family is not an uncomplicated natural unit, but it is about power equations and repression. Doshi would agree with Rushdie. Her unnamed protagonist had entered into matrimony with high expectations and had devoted herself to her family and how things come apart: " If I was asked to show how much I loved him, I would have shown it in the endless folding of bedding, tablecloths, dish towels….How I placed my hand in scalding water and did not flinch." The inverse relationship between knowledge and love: "To love was to not know. To be faithful was to look resolutely away from knowing." Even her own natal family- despite their show of care, concern and support- is not willing to empathise with her. Their love for her is not unconditional. Her own sister is concerned and envious of her by turns. The novel raises perceptive questions: Is the love that family extends to its members unconditional? What about the erasure of identity, especially that of female identity? What about unequal distribution of responsibilities? The narrator's complicated relationship with her demanding parents and somewhat eccentric sister reveals how childhood experiences, obedience to or defiance of familial expectations and emotional injuries continue to shape adult behaviour.

Identity, agency and redemption

"As he spoke, I felt inside me a sudden winter." From the apparent implosion of identity constructed around one individual, one institution, she feels fractured and fragmented. She wallows between self-pity and bitterness. And yet, the way she discovers herself, develops her own agency, overcomes the fear of water and renews herself at the Kumbhmela at Sangam- they mark not the fulfilment of redemption but the beginning of a process of renewal. Instead of defining herself in terms of a marriage- based single identity, she is part of the protean, multiple, diverse and abundant.

While her first novel, Burnt Sugar centres on the complex mother- daughter relationship, The First House explores the fragility of the singularity of identity centred around institutions of marriage and family that, among other things, are about oppressive power equations and relationships. Maybe, there are too many metaphors with too much details which at times appear incongruous. At places, the psychological observations appear distinct and separate from the actual narrative. But all in all, it makes for a really good read- not exactly unputdownable but engaging, intimate and stimulating.

Sanjay Kumar is an IAS Officer, Bihar Cadre; Views presented are personal.