Author: Lucky Kulkarni
Why workplaces sometimes punish the people who dare to challenge the norm. There is a Japanese proverb that says, “The nail that sticks out gets hammered down.”
It is a simple image, but it describes a powerful reality inside many workplaces. Organisations often say they want people who think differently. They put innovation, courage and challenging the status quo on their walls. Leaders ask employees to “speak up” and “bring new ideas to the table.”
But what happens when someone actually does? Sometimes, the welcome is not quite as enthusiastic. The employee who questions an established process may be called difficult. The Head of the Department who challenges a senior leader may be labelled negative or not aligning with the company or people. The person who asks why something has always been done in a particular way may be told, “This is how we work here.”
Slowly, people learn the lesson. Do not be the nail that sticks out. Conformity rarely arrives with an official policy. It develops quietly. People watch what happens to colleagues who disagree, challenge authority or raise uncomfortable questions. If those individuals are ignored, isolated or passed over, others notice. Some employees accept the situation and quietly continue working. But talented employees rarely remain silent for long. They disengage, quietly explore their options, and eventually take their talent-and sometimes valuable business knowledge-to the competition. Soon, silence becomes safer than honesty. And that is where organisations can lose something far more valuable than an occasional good idea: the willingness of people to think independently. Organisations need discipline, consistency and the ability to make decisions. Leaders cannot run businesses where every decision becomes an endless debate. A senior executive who says, “I disagree, and here is why,” may be protecting the organisation from a decision that has not been sufficiently examined. An employee who asks a question that nobody else has asked may see a customer problem that senior people have become too accustomed to notice. A manager who says, “We have always done it this way, but perhaps we should reconsider,” may be the person preventing yesterday’s solution from becoming tomorrow’s problem.
The irony is that organisations frequently discover the value of these people only after they leave. The person whose performance was questioned becomes an admired competitor. The employee whose ideas were dismissed develops them elsewhere. Perhaps the real leadership question is therefore not, “Why is this person resisting?” It is: “Why does this person feel the need to resist?” Sometimes the nail sticks out because it is badly positioned. But sometimes it sticks out because the structure- in fact, the leader around needs to change. Leaders have a responsibility to know the difference. The strongest organisations are not those where every nail is perfectly aligned. They are those where people can safely ask, “Why?” Because conformity can create order. But thoughtful dissent can create progress. And if every nail is hammered down, eventually nobody remains willing to tell the carpenter that the structure is being built in the wrong direction.
The author is a senior corporate HR leader, writer and people strategist; Views presented are personal.