I am getting calls from flat buyers day and night. Some call me at night saying that their tap was not working, Attorney General R Venkataramani told the Supreme Court on Monday as he sought permission to be relieved of his responsibilities as ‘court receiver’ of Amrapali Group properties due to workload.
A bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and K Vinod Chadran urged the country’s top law officer not to exit at least till 2030 and told him, “Sometimes, we may have to undertake work that we may not like. But it’s alright. Just a little more time. We will sort it out.”
Venkataramani said that he has been handling the responsibilities of ‘court receiver’ since 2019 and now he wants to exit due to the workload and other commitments.
Justice Pardiwala told him, “You want to exit? And then who will enter? You have done so much, and ultimately, we are all doing this for the homebuyers who have been put into difficulty.”
“There could be some dubious homebuyers as well. You have to weed them out. If there are any mischievous transactions, you have to look into them. We humbly request you not to exit. At least until August 11, 2030, please do not withdraw. From August 12, 2030, you can withdraw,” Justice Pardiwala said, referring to his date of retirement as a judge of the apex court.
The bench assured Venkataramani that things will be sorted out eventually and no homebuyers will harass him.
“Nobody will harass you except the two of us. We have that privilege, and we may exercise it. But don’t worry, we will try to put an end to it. When you have done so much, and ultimately we are all doing it, we have to see this through,” the bench told the AG. It asked the counsel for home buyers to ensure that individual homebuyers do not bother the AG with their personal complaints and harass him.
“The Attorney General has many other tensions on his head,” the top court told the home buyers.
The top court is hearing pleas of over 100 Amrapali Group homebuyers since 2017 after they approached the court for safeguarding their interests as the Bank of Baroda had moved NCLT for initiating insolvency proceedings against the real estate company.
The apex court had in July 2019 appointed Venkataramani as court receiver, who became the custodian of the properties of Amrapali Group, and entrusted the work for completion of the stalled projects to NBCC.
During the hearing, the top court sought detailed status reports from the Ventaramani, NBCC, which was entrusted with the completion of stalled projects of Amrapali Group in 2019, Noida and Greater Noida authorities, and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on the progress made in completing the housing projects and handing over possession to homebuyers.
It asked the stakeholders to explain the steps taken pursuant to its 2019 judgment and specify further measures required to ensure that genuine homebuyers receive possession at the earliest, while dubious flat buyers are identified and weeded out.
It fixed the matter for further hearing on December 7, saying it would consider the prayer made by homebuyers for attachment of properties belonging to the Amrapali Group’s promoters and builders and their auction to recover money for completing the pending projects.
Venkataramani said that around 7,000 homebuyers were still awaiting possession of their flats and pointed out that several homebuyers had not come forward to register themselves or deposit the balance payment for their homes.
Advocate ML Lahoty, along with advocate Anchit Sripat, appearing for the homebuyers, also placed a note before the court detailing the outstanding issues concerning recovery of diverted funds, completion of projects and handover of flats.
The bench said it would examine Lahoty’s note and asked the other stakeholders to place their respective accounts of the developments and the action taken.
Lahoty, in his note, said that of the 46,575 units, 8,538 units were already in the possession of homebuyers at the time of appointment of NBCC. Hence, only 38,037 units were required to be completed.
“Over the years, NBCC have constructed 33,250 units, but possession has been given to only around 22,350 homebuyers and approximately 10,900 homebuyers are still awaiting the handover of their units notwithstanding more than 15 years of delay,” the homebuyers said.
They said the funds for the projects, which were diverted by the promoters and officials of the erstwhile Amrapali Group, need to be recovered from them.
Lahoty said that out of the diverted Rs. 5,619.47 crore of the homebuyers’ money as dealt with by the top court in its 2019 judgement, only Rs. 744.81 crore has been recovered till date.
He said the major recovery of Rs. 2,159.32 crores was due from Promoters/Directors and others.
Over 46,575 homebuyers who booked their flats in 28 projects/sub-projects of Amrapali in Noida and Greater Noida during the period of 2011-12 were stranded as the projects remained incomplete, while their money amounting to Rs. 5619.47 crores had been siphoned off/diverted by the promoters/directors and key managerial personnel of Amrapali.
The apex court, in its July 23, 2019, verdict, had cracked the whip on errant builders for breaching the trust reposed by the homebuyers, and ordered the cancellation of Amrapali Group’s registration under real estate law RERA, and ousted it from prime properties in the NCR by nixing land leases.