India

Row after Sena leader tears Bal Thackeray photo at Sonia book protest

Pioneer News Service

A protest by Shiv Sena leaders against Sonia Gandhi’s remarks about VD Savarkar in her memoir took a twist on Wednesday when party member Shaina NC inadvertently tore a paper with a photo of the late Sena founder Bal Thackeray.

The Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena had organised a press conference where party leaders, including Shaina tore copies of the book — ‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’. The party also sought to corner the rival Sena (UBT), which is at present a Congress ally. Apart from Shaina, Shiv Sena leaders Sanjay Nirupam, Sheetal Mhatre, Anand Dubey and others were present at the press conference.

They protested against Gandhi, who in her memoir has said that Hindutva ideologue Savarkar wrote mercy petitions to the British and RSS members colluded with British authorities as informers. The Sena leaders tore pages of the memoir. Photos of Shiv Sena (UBT) leaders, including its chief Uddhav Thackeray, were also torn.

Shaina, however, inadvertently tore a paper with a photograph of Bal Thackeray slapping an effigy of former Union minister and Congress veteran Mani Shankar Aiyar.

Someone pointed out to her the faux pas. Startled, she was seen whispering ‘sorry’, and putting the partly-torn paper on the table.

The Opposition Shiv Sena (UBT), Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) and Congress seized on the incident, protesting against Shaina. Shaina took to X to defend herself, claiming that she had torn Mani Shankar Aiyar’s image, not Bal Thackeray’s.

“Show me where I have torn or disrespected Hindu Hriday Samrat Balasaheb Thackeray’s photograph. Deliberately twisting an incident to create a false narrative will not be tolerated. Anyone spreading defamatory claims will face legal action,” she said in a post on X.

Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde also defended her, saying that Bal Thackeray was like God to them and no Shiv Sena member can insult him.  Shaina had immediately clarified that she tore Aiyar’s image, not Thackeray’s, Shinde said.

Those rejected by people are defaming the Shiv Sena, Shinde said in an apparent swipe at the Uddhav Thackeray-led Sena (UBT). Congress leader Rahul Gandhi had also made insulting remarks against Savarkar, Shinde said.

“I condemn those who sit next to them and also those who have abandoned the ideals of Balasaheb,” Shinde said in a veiled attack on Uddhav Thackeray and his party. Meanwhile, Shiv Sena (UBT) and MNS corporators walked out of the general body meeting of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to protest against Shaina NC.

Shiv Sena (UBT) supporters also staged protests in different parts of Maharashtra. Party leader Anil Parab said Eknath Shinde should himself “beat his party leader with a footwear” for the act.

Congress leaders Balasaheb Thorat and Vijay Wadettiwar condemned the tearing of pages from Sonia Gandhi’s book saying differences with its content should be expressed through a democratic debate rather than acts of vandalism.

Thorat said people were entitled to disagree with the views expressed in a book, but they should read it and debate its contents.

“Trying to gain publicity by tearing a book is unfortunate,” he said.

Taking a swipe at the Shiv Sena, Thorat alleged that many of its leaders had switched parties to remain close to power. It was ridiculous for the people who did not know their own political history to comment on Sonia Gandhi’s life journey, he said.

Differences of opinion in public life should be expressed in a civilised manner, the senior leader said.

Wadettiwar said tearing pages of a book can neither erase history nor suppress the truth.

“If you disagree with the ideas in a book, oppose them democratically, express your views or even write a separate book. But tearing its pages in an attempt to silence ideas goes against the values of freedom of expression,” he said.

The Congress leader alleged that the act exposed the ideological bankruptcy of those opposing the book.

In a swipe at Sanjay Nirupam, a former Congressman, Wadettiwar said leaders should respect democratic values and freedom of expression instead of surrendering before the RSS’ ideology for power.

Thorat said Sonia Gandhi’s sacrifice, struggles and dedication to the country had been witnessed closely by Congress leaders, and the book offered readers an opportunity to understand her life journey in her own words.

He expressed confidence that the controversy would prompt more people to read the book.

Mumbai Congress president Varsha Gaikwad said those present at the Sena press conference, including Sanjay Nirupam, have no ideological commitment, party loyalty or affection for the people.

Shaina’s act was an insult to Maharashtra’s identity, the Mumbai North Central MP said.