Author: Madhav Nair | CA Sumeet Mehta
India’s debate on the proposed divestiture of IDBI Bank by the Government of India to Fairfax Holdings needs to move beyond the age old conventional and hence conservative arguments of public versus private ownership.
At a time when the country aspires to become a developed economy, the more important question is whether our financial institutions have the capital, technology, professional expertise, and management capabilities to support the next phase of economic growth.
The proposed transaction is an important milestone in Indian banking. Yet, much of the public discourse has focused on valuation, foreign ownership, employee interests, and the future of a bank that has recently returned to profitability. These concerns rightfully deserve scrutiny, but they should not overshadow the larger strategic opportunity.
Why strategic ownership matters
Banking is undergoing profound transformation. Artificial intelligence, digital distribution, changing customer expectations, cybersecurity and competition from fintech companies are redefining the industry. Banks need sustained investments in technology, talent, analytics, risk management and digital infrastructure. Equally important are strategic vision, managerial agility and accountability.
Ownership is therefore not merely about who holds the shares. It is about who brings the capital, capabilities, and leadership required to build a sustainable institution. This is where Fairfax, led by Prem Watsa, could make a meaningful difference. Its established presence in India’s financial services sector, including its investment in CSB Bank and interests in insurance and capital markets, offers relevant experience.
The proposed integration of Fairfax’s interests in Digit’s insurance businesses and IIFL Capital into the IDBI ecosystem, subject to necessary approvals, could create a broader financial services platform spanning banking, insurance, investment banking and wealth management. Such a combination could expand customer offerings, improve distribution economics, create cross-selling opportunities and strengthen the bank’s ability to serve retail customers, MSMEs and corporates. For an economy where financial services penetration still has considerable headroom, this presents a significant opportunity.
Public interest is not synonymous with public ownership
Perhaps the most fundamental misconception in this debate is that reducing Government ownership necessarily amounts to a loss of public interest.
Public-sector banks have made an invaluable contribution to financial inclusion, priority-sector lending, rural outreach, and implementation of Government programmes.
However, public ownership by itself does not guarantee efficiency, superior governance, or better customer outcomes. Equally, private ownership does not automatically guarantee success.
What ultimately matters is professional management, strong governance, regulatory supervision, and institutional accountability.
India’s private-sector banks have demonstrated that private capital and professional management can contribute significantly to credit growth, innovation, employment and financial inclusion.
IDBI Bank will continue to operate within the RBI’s regulatory framework. Its obligations relating to priority-sector lending, financial inclusion, depositor protection and other applicable requirements will remain intact. The Government and LIC will also retain stakes of 15 per cent and 19 per cent respectively following the proposed transaction, ensuring continuing institutional participation. The objective should be to strengthen the institution rather than preserve an ownership structure as an end in itself.
Public interest is best served not by ownership alone, but by strong institutions that deliver value to customers, employees, shareholders and the economy.
Protecting employees, customers and depositors
The concerns of employees cannot be overlooked. As this article is being written, the employees of IDBI Bank have called for a strike on 3rd December, 2026 to protest against this divestment deal. These employees have been integral to the bank’s recovery and deserve due recognition. The employees carry genuine concerns relating to employment continuity, job security, service conditions, pensions, retirement benefits, and career progression. The Government of India and the Management of IDBI Bank and the incoming investor (Fairfax) must address this transparently.
At the same time, the incoming investor needs to instil confidence in the bank employees that they will bring with them cutting edge state of the art knowledge, experience, and insights into how the bank will grow on the back of growth of employees. This will require Fairfax to also highlight how it brings with itself learning and development programs and tools for the employees to help them be amongst the most competitive and qualified banking professionals in the country who will command respect and premium value in the market place.
Here it is pertinent for everyone to observe how private banks like ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank, etc have not only performed on financial front.
The cognisance of the efficient and aggressive management with excellently trained team have been a market leader in bringing up innovative products for both — the borrowers and the depositors.
This comes on the back of excellent training and development of individuals and teams and bringing in competitive professionalism in workplace.
Private sector banks also have much required operational flexibility and agility to introduce, amend and improve its offerings based on market conditions and customer response. This goes unsaid that Fairfax has no option but to bring these on the table to recover its investments by growing the bank faster than its own estimates. Similarly, depositor confidence must remain paramount.
A larger opportunity for Viksit Bharat
The significance of this transaction extends beyond one bank. India’s ambition of becoming a developed economy by 2047 will require a deeper and more sophisticated financial system capable of financing infrastructure, manufacturing, MSMEs, housing, renewable energy and emerging technologies. Banks will be central to this transformation, but they must increasingly operate as part of a wider financial services ecosystem. Strategic partnerships, professional capital, technology and global expertise can strengthen this ecosystem.
The Fairfax proposal offers an opportunity to combine IDBI Bank’s established franchise, customer base and distribution network with complementary financial services capabilities and investment experience.
This is not a guarantee of success. The real test will be execution, governance, investment in technology and sustainable value creation over the coming decade.
India’s economic history, from the 1991 liberalisation to the opening of several sectors to private investment, demonstrates how structural reforms can create long-term value despite initial resistance.
The IDBI transaction should be viewed in a similar context. The debate must move beyond whether a bank is publicly or privately owned. The relevant questions are whether it is adequately capitalised, professionally managed, technologically competitive and capable of supporting a rapidly growing economy.
The RBI’s fit-and-proper assessment and other regulatory approvals provide important safeguards for an orderly transition.
Ultimately, the success of this landmark transaction will not be measured by the change in shareholding. It will be measured by what IDBI Bank becomes over the next ten to fifteen years and the contribution it makes to India’s economic aspirations. That is the larger perspective from which this transaction deserves to be judged.
Madhav Nair is a Senior Banker, CA Sumeet Mehta is a Corporate Finance professional and author of the book: Diagnosing GST for Doctors; Views presented are personal.