In India, public perception over safety, crime prevention, communal harmony, narcotics control and security matter a lot and they have become increasingly complex governance challenges. Hence, the Home Department remains one of the most consequential portfolios in a state government. That is why from largest state Uttar Pradesh’s Chief Minister (CM) Yogi Adityanath to the Smallest State’s CM Dr Pramod Sawant, hold the Home Portfolio. Other states where CMs retain the Home portfolio include Maharashtra, Assam, West Bengal, Odisha, Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Punjab. They have take up this responsibility of a direct control of policing as it strengthens coordination and decision making. However, the real measure lies in transparent performance, institutional independence, public safety and overall public perception on their governance and accountability.
Several Chief Ministers have chosen to retain Home, believing that direct supervision allows quicker decision-making, stronger coordination, and clearer accountability. Among them are prominent leaders such as Yogi Adityanath in Uttar Pradesh, Devendra Fadnavis in Maharashtra, Himanta Biswa Sarma in Assam, Suvendu Adhikari in West Bengal, Mohan Yadav in Madhya Pradesh, Bhajan Lal Sharma in Rajasthan, Pushkar Singh Dhami in Uttarakhand, Bhagwant Mann in Punjab and Dr Pramod Sawant in Goa.
The Home Department is considered sensitive as it oversees the police, law-and-order arrangements, security infrastructure, intelligence coordination, prison administration and other related institutions. A Chief Minister holding Home can directly review police performance, intervene in administrative bottlenecks, coordinate with district authorities and respond to crises without depending on another minister's political or administrative priorities.
But centralisation has its limitations. The Home Department is an enormous operational system, with thousands of police personnel, multiple district units, specialised agencies, intelligence networks, forensic institutions and a large volume of routine administrative decisions. A Chief Minister simultaneously handling finance, personnel, development, party management and political affairs may not have sufficient time for continuous oversight of policing. The effectiveness of the arrangement therefore depends less on the portfolio's political ownership and more on the quality of the professional machinery, delegation, monitoring systems and institutional discipline.
Chief Ministers such as Yogi Adityanath, Devendra Fadnavis and Himanta Biswa Sarma have retained Home as part of their broader governance approach. Their states face distinctly different challenges. Uttar Pradesh must manage a vast population, complex law-and-order demands and urban-rural policing. Maharashtra's challenges include metropolitan crime, organised criminal networks, industrial security, and the administration of a large police force. Assam has additional concerns involving border security, insurgency-related issues, migration. and regional security.
Similarly, the Home portfolio in smaller states can be particularly demanding despite a comparatively smaller population. Geography, tourism, border exposure, social diversity, urbanisation and the nature of economic activity can create specialised security requirements. In Goa, the challenges include maintaining public safety in a major tourist destination, narcotics trafficking, coastal security, cybercrime, traffic management, foreigner-related violations, and the protection of a fragile social and environmental ecosystem.
Goa offers an interesting case study in the Chief Minister retaining the Home portfolio. CM Dr Pramod Sawant, not only holds the Home Department, but several other key departments. His governance approach has increasingly involved coordination with central agencies, modernisation of policing, technology-driven administration and a focus on strengthening institutional response. For a small state with a high tourist inflow and significant coastal exposure, maintaining law and order is closely linked with its economic reputation. The safety of tourists, residents, businesses and investors directly affects Goa's tourism-led economy.
The state has also been working on the implementation of the new criminal laws and the Interoperable Criminal Justice System (ICJS), which seeks to improve coordination between police, courts, prisons, forensic laboratories and other institutions. During a September 2026 review meeting chaired by Union Home Minister Amit Shah alongside Sawant, state officials reported an increase in the conviction rate from 22 per cent to 53 per cent and said several criminal cases were being disposed of within six to eight months. The review also highlighted coastal security, cybercrime, narcotics-related offences, and the movement of criminals across state boundaries as priority areas.
This improvement, if sustained and measured consistently, could indicate progress in investigation, prosecution coordination, and the use of technology. Goa Police's response time under the emergency helpline 112 was also reported to have improved from 18 minutes to eight minutes. Goa Police's President's Colour (September 2026), the State's first rank in the BPR&D's February 2026 assessment of the three new criminal laws, and Bicholim Police Station's fifth national rank in 2025 offer concrete markers of progress. Initiatives such as Spot the Scam, the Radical Content Analyser and the Pink Force also illustrate technology-led, citizen-focused policing.
Reacting to allegations of increasing gang violence and zero fear of the police in the state by Goa Congress, CM Pramod Sawant accuses opposition parties and the INDIA bloc of attempting to create anarchy and unrest in the country. Emphasising his zero-tolerance approach on violence and "goondagiri," he says, “I have given a complete power to Goa Police to act firmly in the interest of law and order, and I urge everyone to respect their authority and cooperate with our police personnel in maintaining peace and security across the State.”
In Goa, the CM’s approach towards institutional autonomy and professional policing is particularly valuable. The state's compact geography offers the advantage of relatively close coordination, but its tourism-driven economy, coastal vulnerabilities, seasonal population fluctuations, and emerging cyber and drug-related threats require constant preparedness. Stronger intelligence-sharing, community policing, modern surveillance with safeguards, forensic capacity, coastal coordination and victim-sensitive policing must be part of a comprehensive security strategy.
It is evident that the Home portfolio is a huge responsibility to protect citizens and uphold the rule of law. Chief Ministers who retain it have an opportunity to demonstrate that concentrated political leadership can deliver efficient, responsive and accountable policing. Goa presents a success story and for the state the next phase must focus on independently verifiable outcomes, stronger investigations, prevention of narcotics and cybercrime, transparent police accountability and greater public confidence. Finally, public perception is the key. Citizens should feel safer, justice is delivered faster, policing is impartial and institutions become stronger. Political control may centralise authority, but only institutional performance can legitimise it.
The writer is a senior journalist and columnist with over three decades of experience. He writes extensively on rural affairs, agriculture, economic issues, healthcare and public policy, with a particular focus on developments impacting the grassroots economy and rural communities; Views presented are personal.