Analysis

Padma awards: Reforming India’s civilian honours system

Subhash Chandra Agrawal

India’s highest civilian honours must reflect merit, integrity and national service, not political considerations. Greater transparency, stricter scrutiny, uniformity in selection and clear criteria for withdrawing awards are essential to preserve the credibility and prestige of the Bharat Ratna and Padma awards.

Few honours a republic bestows carry the weight of the Bharat Ratna and the three Padma awards: the Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Shri. Yet these honours have rarely been free of controversy. The UPA years in particular saw too many instances of the awards being cheapened, handed out for political convenience rather than merit. Names reached the list that should never have been considered: people with criminal antecedents, those accused of tax evasion or of amassing unaccounted wealth by unfair means, and defaulters on bank loans.

The awards have even been suspended twice, from 1977 to 1980 and again from 1992 to 1995, when their legitimacy was challenged in court. They resumed only after the Supreme Court, in Balaji Raghavan v. Union of India (1995), upheld their validity and called for norms to keep selection merit-based. Three decades on, that promise remains unfulfilled. The system needs structural reform, and eight changes would go a long way.

Fixing the structure

First, the awards’ design. Grading roughly 130 awardees a year into three tiers, in a nation of over 1.4 billion, diminishes the Padma Shri by placing it beneath the Padma Bhushan and Padma Vibhushan. A single, merged Padma award would restore its worth and make room for more deserving people. A sizeable share of each year’s list also goes to “upgrades”, people already decorated in earlier years. A Padma award should be conferred once in a lifetime; only the Bharat Ratna should remain open to existing Padma awardees.

Second, nominations need discipline. An individual should be allowed to recommend just one name. Ministries, departments and constitutional authorities, including the President, Vice-President, Prime Minister, Union ministers, Governors and Chief Ministers, can retain the freedom to recommend more through their secretariats. During the UPA years, the AICC treasurer was reported to have forwarded an excessive number of names, burdening the scrutiny process and inviting suspicion of a please-all policy, or even of fund-raising for the party.

Third, vetting must come first. Every nominee should be cleared by intelligence and tax authorities before the list reaches the Awards Committee. Members would then study only a lean, pre-cleared list closely.

Fourth, the selection machinery must be insulated from the Government of the day. Today the Prime Minister constitutes the Awards Committee, headed by the Cabinet Secretary. Instead, its members should be chosen by consensus between the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, with a nominee of the Opposition Leader on the panel. A higher Selection Committee, chaired by the Vice-President, should include the Central Vigilance Commissioner, with the Cabinet Secretary as its secretary. Every effort should be made to choose awardees by consensus.

Fifth, the Bharat Ratna should be conferred only with the agreement of the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition. That would guard against its misuse for political ends, a charge levelled at some past awards, including one to a prominent South Indian political leader.

Sixth, these honours should be reserved for resident Indians. Overseas Indians already have the Pravasi Bharatiya Samman, and India confers international honours such as the Gandhi Peace Prize. Yet the 2026 list again included six foreign nationals or overseas Indians.

Seventh, transparency. Once the awards are announced on the eve of Republic Day, the Home Ministry’s website should publish the entire process: every name considered, who recommended each, and when nominations reached the recommending authority and the Ministry.

Eighth, Nobel laureates, medal winners at recognised international events and Indians who have set world records, including entries in the Guinness Book of World Records, should be automatic choices.

When honour turns to embarrassment

Honours should also be withdrawn when recipients are later found wanting, and the examples are uncomfortable. An Olympic-medallist wrestler and Padma Shri awardee was arrested by Delhi Police on May 23, 2021 in the killing of a junior wrestler, after his anticipatory bail plea had been rejected; he remains an accused, and the Delhi High Court refused him bail as recently as August 2026. A film actor was drawn into a criminal case. A former chief of a leading private bank, a Padma Bhushan, was arrested by the CBI in a loan case, and in 2025 an appellate tribunal held that she had taken a bribe to sanction a loan.

Even in 2026, a popular film actor, already a Padma Bhushan, was posthumously given the Padma Vibhushan, though he had married a second time while his first wife was alive and undivorced, amid long-standing reports, which he denied, that he had converted to Islam for that purpose. Many also wondered why his second wife, not his first, received the award. Such cases question how intelligence agencies clear names, and whether they do so under pressure from those in power. Nominees should file affidavits declaring that they face no such controversies. The list of nominees should be made public so citizens can send objections to the Selection Committee. Agencies must get enough time to verify names before the Awards Committee submits its final recommendations.

A mixed record

Since the NDA came to power, there has been a genuine effort to find unsung heroes, many from poor rural backgrounds, irrespective of caste or religion. Mohammed Sharif of Ayodhya, a bicycle mechanic who began performing the last rites of unclaimed bodies, each according to the deceased’s faith, after his son was murdered in 1992, has given more than 25,000 people a dignified farewell. His Padma Shri in 2020 honoured the award as much as the man. Yet inconsistencies persist. In 2020, former Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar received a posthumous Padma Bhushan, while departed leaders of similar stature, Arun Jaitley and Sushma Swaraj, received the Padma Vibhushan. More startling was the posthumous Padma Vibhushan in 2023 to a former Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister and Opposition stalwart. Reserving Padma awards for prominent politicians merely to display bipartisanship is an unhealthy tradition.

Honours still owed

Controversies apart, some honours are overdue. Veer Savarkar’s admirers recall that Lal Bahadur Shastri’s Government sanctioned him a monthly pension that had not materialised under Jawaharlal Nehru. Indira Gandhi praised him and issued a commemorative stamp in his honour in 1970, and even the Shiv Sena (UBT), now a Congress ally, has sought the Bharat Ratna for him. Savarkar also resisted orthodoxy: he told his family not to perform the tenth- and thirteenth-day rituals after his death, and was cremated electrically rather than on a wood pyre. Recognition has often come late. Sardar Patel received the Bharat Ratna only in 1991, while the present Government honoured Nanaji Deshmukh posthumously in 2019. Revolutionaries Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Rajguru and Ashfaqulla Khan deserve the same. So do newsreader Devki Nandan Pandey, playback singer Mukesh, ghazal maestro Jagjit Singh and industrialist Ratan Tata, who would join Bharat Ratnas Lata Mangeshkar and Ustad Bismillah Khan. To its credit, this Government conferred the Bharat Ratna on Congress veteran Pranab Mukherjee in 2019 and, in 2024, on PV Narasimha Rao, long ignored by his own party. National honours must reward merit alone, never political convenience, if they are to endure.

A single, merged Padma award would restore its worth and make room for more deserving people. A sizeable share of each year’s list also goes to “upgrades”, people already decorated in earlier years. A Padma award should be conferred once in a lifetime; only the Bharat Ratna should remain open to existing Padma awardees. Honours should be withdrawn when recipients are later found wanting.

Writer is Guinness World Record Holder for writing most letters and RTI Consultant; Views presented are personal.