By bringing right-holder families out of isolated forest interiors and settling them in better, contiguous regions, the State can deliver genuine social mobility. This approach can provide to the FRA beneficiaries direct access to healthcare, education, and stable employment while allowing the degraded forest plots to naturally regenerate
The Forest Rights Act 2006 (FRA) was passed with the objective of recognising the forest rights on forest lands, targeting the statutorily defined Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes (FDSTs) and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (OTFDs) who, as mentioned in the preamble itself, have been residing in such forests for generations but whose rights could not be recorded. Recently, FAO’s district-level soil mapping has been used to declare the crop suitability of forest land having Individual Forest Rights (IFR). Considering the associated factors linked with intensive farming, the proposal to develop the IFR lands into oilseed and pulse production clusters with market linkages and institutional credit across forest lands with Individual Forest Rights (IFR) of ‘self-cultivation’ under Section 3(1)(a) of the FRA, however, presents an ecological and economic paradox.
While the intention to uplift the FRA’s beneficiaries appears progressive on paper, the proposed framework rests on flawed agrarian economics and a troubling obliviousness of forest ecology. Anchoring FDSTs and OTFDs to isolated, refractory forest patches under the banner of agricultural development creates, prima facie, a deep economic vulnerability for them, a situation of permanent human-wildlife conflict, and an inescapable trap of overall ecological destruction. The spatial and economic reality of the forest lands under IFR of ‘self-cultivation’ is that these plots are predominantly tiny, highly fragmented micro-holdings occupied historically for subsistence. Both before and after Independence, arable lands were systematically diverted for farming and infrastructure-a practice the National Forest Policy of 1952 sought to halt by asserting the forest’s intrinsic right to land.
Repeated waves of forest encroachment regularisation, however, continued even on the inherently refractory soils in forest areas. FRA essentially had to recognise the forest rights that escaped all such attempts. As regards the average size, a 2013 study of randomly selected 36,600 cases in Maharashtra showed that 43% of IFR recognitions averaged a mere 1.3 acres.
Forest-interior intensive farming would threaten biodiversity, and agrochemicals would pollute water pathways and food webs, poisoning non-target flora and fauna, while increased human footprint in forests would escalate human-wildlife conflict. This dynamic is already starkly evident in the states of Kerala, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Assam, Odisha, Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh, showing increasing trends over recent years. It has led to an alarming rise in fatal animal attacks, widespread crop raiding, and retaliatory wildlife killings.
The administrative push to build scattered support systems-such as micro-irrigation, storage units, and road networks-for lakhs of isolated, pockmarked plots across forest interiors is both economically inefficient and ecologically damaging. Worse still, bringing resource-poor forest dwellers into credit-dependent farming regimes will expose them to severe financial distress. Indian agrarian reality is already plagued by input-cost inflation, debt traps, and climate volatility, factors directly linked to the ongoing crisis of farmer suicides in central India.
Forcing FRA beneficiaries to rely on institutional credit and volatile market prices for survival on marginal land threatens to replicate the tragic debt cycles inside tribal belts. As soil productivity inevitably declines over time due to nutrient depletion, impoverished farmers will face immense pressure to clear adjacent forest lands to maintain yields. This will, apart from criminalising their livelihood, expand the size and number of pockmarks across the landscape, converting dense forest ecosystems into fragmented islands of poverty-stricken communities.
The approach of using FAO’s district-level soil mapping data for declaring crop suitability of plots inside forest areas is logically flawed, as coarse regional soil data cannot predict interior forest land’s suitability. Ironically, India’s own land classification strictly separates agricultural from forest lands using realistic, site-specific parameters to boost agrarian output safely. It should, however, be noted that categorising forest plots erroneously as high-yield farmland risks a dangerous triggering of land conflict, deforestation, and diversion of forest areas. The environmental fallout of action taken to convert these plots into high-yield agricultural nodes would be catastrophic. Any introduction of intensive farming, localised irrigation schemes, processing units, and transport links would disrupt contiguous forest canopy, causing severe habitat fragmentation. Unlike past encroachment regularisation drives, the FRA process lacks any focus on buffer restrictions near water bodies and on slopes. As per a 2013 Maharashtra study, 15% of cases lie within 50 meters of streams, and many on slopes above 10%. In hilly areas and Himalayan regions, intensive farming on fragile slopes and riverbeds would accelerate soil erosion, landslides, and siltation during the rainy season, threatening both agriculture and the core forest ecosystems. The examples of extensive damage in the Western Ghats, the Himalayan states of Himachal and Uttarakhand, Kerala, Assam, and Maharashtra, triggered by land-breaking, are indicative.
This ecological threat is compounded by widespread procedural abuse in the implementation of FRA, where ineligible occupants exploit Section 4(5) to prevent their eviction; District Level Committees, the final authorities in the matter, continue to do mass irregular recognitions without proper scrutiny. Just to quote some cases, IFRs are granted in hundreds of cases to more than one applicant on the same plots in Bhadradri Kothagudem District and on thousands of podu land plots by rejecting satellite image-based evidence in Telangana. IFRs have been granted on exactly one-acre plots to more than 66 per cent of applicants in Balgan Taluka of Nasik in Maharashtra, and exactly two-acre plots have been granted to a large number of claimants in the same district. Again, Community Forest Resource Rights have been granted over 1.9 crore acres of the Forest Department’s forest area in the country without meeting legal criteria. Extending state benefits in such unauthorised cases to claimants constitutes a double illegality that misallocates public funds and legitimises unlawful action.
Historically, forest communities, with far smaller populations compared to today, depended not just on sedentary crop farming alone; their sustained survival included a diversified portfolio of minor forest produce (MFP) collection, livestock grazing, seasonal wage labour, and foraging. Any attempt to drive their socio-economic mobility today by forcing intensive agriculture onto IFR plots, expanding CFRRs onto ineligible forest lands, and exceeding legal limits for MFP and grazing will, in the long run, simply overburden the exhausted forests and trap the huge population in a cycle of diminishing returns. Intensive agriculture, after all, is a form of "resource mining" in contrast to a forest ecosystem that preserves ecological stability and supports broader landscapes far beyond forest borders.
Policymakers must adopt a sustainable and ecologically grounded approach towards the development of the beneficiaries of FRA rather than anchoring vulnerable populations precariously to broken, isolated plots exposed to extreme weather, unviable yields, and relentless crop raiding in the name of unlocking the agri-potential of FRA lands. The true solution lies in offering fair, attractive, and voluntary resettlement & rehabilitation packages, keeping the ‘nature’ and ‘extent’ of their forest rights intact on the alternate site. Till the time that is done, the right holders should be encouraged to cultivate local minor forest produce, including medicinal plants and go for horticultural and silvicultural species rather than intensive monoculture or commercial crop expansion.
Sustainable development requires respecting ecological thresholds, protecting forest health, respecting nature’s intrinsic right to exist and transitioning toward sustainable, non-extractive economic alternatives outside the overburdened forest ecosystem. By bringing right-holder families out of isolated forest interiors and settling them in better, contiguous regions, the State can deliver genuine social mobility. This approach can provide to the FRA beneficiaries direct access to healthcare, education, appropriate infrastructure, and stable employment while allowing the degraded forest plots to naturally regenerate and heal wildlife habitats and safeguarding simultaneously the national biodiversity for generations to come.
Forest-interior intensive farming would threaten biodiversity, and agrochemicals would pollute water pathways and food webs, poisoning non-target flora and fauna, while increased human footprint in forests would escalate human-wildlife conflict
The writers are former PCCFs of UP and Maharashtra; Views presented are personal.