Agenda

Thanksgiving: Four centuries on a plate

From the modest harvest gathering of 1621 to today’s elaborate spread, Thanksgiving has evolved over four centuries into an enduring American culinary tradition. Its familiar dishes tell a story of history, marketing, immigration and the turkey that remains at the heart of the feast.

Gyaneshwar Dayal

Every fourth Thursday of November, Americans sit down to perhaps the most predictable menu on earth. Turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie arrive with the regularity of a national anthem. Yet a meal that now feels carved in stone took nearly four centuries to assemble.

The 1621 harvest feast at Plymouth, usually called the first Thanksgiving, looked little like today’s spread. The Pilgrims shared three days of eating with some 90 Wampanoag men, and the only foods recorded with certainty are wild fowl and five deer the Wampanoag brought. Corn, shellfish and eels probably featured too. There were no potatoes, and with sugar scarce, no pies or sweetened cranberries.

For two centuries, Thanksgiving days remained scattered, local affairs. The menu we now recognise owes much to Sarah Josepha Hale, a magazine editor who lobbied 17 years for a national holiday and filled her pages with recipes for roast turkey, stuffing and pumpkin pie. Abraham Lincoln obliged in 1863, proclaiming a national day of thanksgiving amid the Civil War, and Hale’s New England table became the nation’s template.

The 20th century added its own layers. Marshmallow-topped sweet potatoes came out of a 1917 marketing booklet; green bean casserole was devised in a Campbell’s test kitchen in 1955; jellied cranberry sauce slid out of cans, ridges intact. Immigrant families quietly set tamales, lasagna and biryani beside the bird, and the feast absorbed them all.

Through every change, one dish has held the centre: the roast turkey. Native to North America, big enough to feed a crowd and festive in a way a chicken never manages, it is less a course than a ceremony, carried in whole, admired, then carved at the head of the table.

It is also the dish most often ruined. The best turkeys start days early with a dry brine: rub the bird with about a teaspoon of salt per kilo and refrigerate it uncovered for two days, which seasons the meat and dries the skin so it crisps. Roast at moderate heat until the thickest part reads 74°C (165°F), then rest it for 30 minutes.

Carve each breast off whole and slice it across the grain, so every slice carries skin. Serve with gravy from the pan drippings and a sharp cranberry sauce to cut the richness. And save the leftovers: for many families, the cold turkey sandwich the next day is the real reward.