

What happens when an industry grows faster than the rules designed to keep it safe? On November 15, the government released a snapshot of India’s rapidly expanding space economy: a $9-billion industry, approximately 440 registered start-ups and more than $618 million in cumulative private investment. It is an extraordinary transformation. But as India prepares to put more private satellites into orbit, there is a question that deserves equal attention: who will pay when one company’s satellite becomes another company’s problem?
Britain has just taken an important step towards answering that question. On November 12, it announced a new framework under which satellite operators demonstrating responsible behaviour can qualify for lower financial liability. The changes, scheduled to apply from December 1, are designed to make companies think about the risks their spacecraft create, not just the commercial returns they generate. For India, this is a timely lesson.
India’s space economy reached approximately $9 billion in August 2026, according to the government’s latest assessment. Around 440 space start-ups are now registered in the country. The transformation is remarkable. Space is no longer the exclusive territory of government scientists and a handful of national agencies. Private companies are developing satellites, launch vehicles and services that could become important parts of the economy.
But more satellites also mean more traffic in an environment where avoiding collisions is becoming increasingly difficult.
In an August parliamentary response, the Department of Space disclosed that ISRO had conducted 20 collision-avoidance manoeuvres in 2025 and another nine in 2026 up to that point. It also reported that 20 of India’s 22 active satellites in low Earth orbit were at higher collision risk. These numbers do not suggest that an accident is inevitable. They reveal how much effort is already required to keep satellites out of one another’s way.
Consider what a collision can do. Two objects travelling at enormous orbital speeds can break into thousands of fragments. Those fragments do not politely fall into the ocean. They can remain in orbit, threatening other spacecraft. A satellite belonging to one company can therefore endanger the communications, navigation or research infrastructure of another. The company that created the problem may not be the only one paying for it.
This is the central weakness in the way we think about the commercialisation of space. We celebrate the company that launches a satellite, but rarely ask what happens when that satellite reaches the end of its useful life, loses control or becomes a hazard to others.
The West is beginning to address this problem in different ways. The United States, for instance, requires licensed commercial launch and re-entry operators to demonstrate financial responsibility. Insurance requirements are based on the estimated maximum probable loss from a mission. The principle is straightforward: companies undertaking riskier activities should not be allowed to leave the resulting costs entirely to the public.
Britain is attempting something different. Its new framework links financial liability to responsible conduct. Operators can qualify for lower liability limits by meeting specified security and sustainability criteria. The idea is worth borrowing: protecting the orbital environment should bring a commercial benefit, not simply another regulatory obligation.
Europe offers a third lesson. Nineteen EU member states participate in a shared space-surveillance partnership that tracks objects, predicts potential collisions and provides warnings to satellite operators. This matters because no company can protect its spacecraft by looking only at its own satellites. It needs information about everything else sharing the same orbital region.
India has already begun developing its own monitoring capabilities through ISRO’s NETRA programme. Its Debris Free Space Mission also aims to make Indian space missions debris-free by 2030. But monitoring alone is not enough. India must connect information about orbital risks with clear financial responsibility.
Here is one idea worth considering: an Orbital Performance Bond.
The principle is familiar from ordinary construction projects. A contractor deposits money as a guarantee that a project will be completed properly. If the obligations are fulfilled, the money is returned. If they are not, the deposit can be used to address the failure.
India could apply a similar principle to satellite operators. Before launching a spacecraft, a company would provide a financial guarantee proportionate to the risk of its mission. The amount would depend on factors such as the satellite’s size, altitude, ability to manoeuvre and plans for disposal after its working life ends.
If the operator safely removes the satellite from its operational orbit or fulfils an approved disposal plan, the guarantee would be returned. If it abandons the spacecraft or fails to meet its obligations, part of the money could be forfeited to support monitoring, mitigation or debris-removal efforts where technically possible.
This is not a replacement for insurance. Insurance pays for covered damage after an accident. The proposed bond would encourage companies to prevent avoidable problems before they occur. Such a system must not become another barrier for India’s young space companies. Smaller start-ups should face requirements proportionate to their missions, with pooled guarantees available where appropriate. The objective is to make space safer without making entry prohibitively expensive.
There is a scientific reason why this matters. Space may look limitless, but useful orbital regions are not. Satellites depend on particular altitudes and paths to perform their work. As the number of objects increases, so does the difficulty of keeping those regions safe. Scientists have long warned about the possibility of a chain reaction of collisions, known as the Kessler syndrome, in which debris from one collision increases the chances of further collisions. It is not an inevitable future, but it is a risk worth preventing.
India should not wait for a major accident to discover the cost of weak rules. It needs a transparent system that makes satellite operators responsible throughout the life of their spacecraft, strengthens the sharing of tracking information and rewards companies that demonstrate responsible behaviour.
The country’s space ambitions should not be measured only by the number of rockets launched or satellites manufactured. They should also be measured by whether the orbital environment remains safe enough for the next generation of companies to use.
India has demonstrated that it can reach space at remarkable cost efficiency. Its next achievement should be ensuring that the space it reaches remains usable. Getting a satellite into orbit is an engineering accomplishment. Keeping that orbit safe is a responsibility.
The author is a physicist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and contributor opinion writer at the Wall Street Journal; Views presented are personal.