

The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that fatwas cannot be binding on any individual and if anybody is compelled to obey such diktats by Muslim clerics, the court will definitely intervene.
During the hearing on a PIl by Vishwa lochan Madan, who challenged the Sharia laws as unconstitutional, the Bench of Justices CK Prasad and PC Ghose said that fatwas have no sanction of any law. The petitioner argued that fatwas issued by muftis is binding on members of the Muslim community, who cannot fully exercise their fundamental rights of life and liberty. Madan cited an instance where a rickshaw puller’s wife who was raped by her father-in-law was ordered by a fatwa to accept her ‘rapist’ father-in-law as her new husband and leave her lawfully married husband.
The Bench pointed out that no statute allowed them (muftis) to issue fatwas and observed that fatwas at best was an advice or an opinion that could be obeyed or rejected by a person. The court added that following fatwas is not mandatory as it has no force of law. At the same time, the Bench assured that it would come to the rescue of those who do not follow such fatwas.
The bench cited similar practices existing in every religion. For instance, it said if a pandit prepares your horoscope and determines your fate, it is up to you to follow or reject it. The muftis, the court held, had no sanction under law. “Anything not sanctioned by the law need not be taken cognizance by anyone,” it said.
When Madan complained that poor and uneducated Muslims can hardly approach the court for protection, the bench reiterated, “Only thing we can do is when somebody is harassed for not following fatwas, the State will protect them.” The All India Muslim Personal law Board through senior advocate Raju Ramachandran shared the views of the bench and said it was purely voluntary for the believers to obey a fatwa. It further supported the judges that if a fatwa violated any fundamental right, the remedy was available by way of recourse to court.