Siang Dam: Security vs indigenous rights

Siang Dam: Security vs indigenous rights
Published on: 

Author: Sabir Nishat

India’s strategic concerns over China’s upstream hydropower ambitions are legitimate, but the proposed 11,200-MW project in Arunachal Pradesh raises difficult questions about displacement, ecological risks and the future of communities whose lives are inseparable from the river

The agitation over the proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) in Arunachal Pradesh has become a test of how India weighs strategic ambition against the rights of people in the path of its megaprojects. Can a dam of such geopolitical value be justified if it uproots indigenous communities and remakes an entire valley?

The government presents the 11,200-megawatt project on the Siang, which becomes the Brahmaputra in Assam, as vital infrastructure and a counterweight to China’s hydropower plans on the Yarlung Tsangpo, as the river is known in Tibet. Yet growing resistance among sections of the Adi community shows that New Delhi’s strategic arithmetic has not answered the fears of those who would bear the cost. Shutdowns, clashes with security forces and the vandalism of an NHPC office in Pasighat reveal how divisive the issue has become. The moment demands dialogue, not escalation.

Why the strategic case matters

India cannot afford complacency upstream. Beijing has announced a giant hydropower scheme near the Great Bend of the Yarlung Tsangpo, reportedly of around 60,000 MW. With no comprehensive water-sharing treaty on the Brahmaputra, fears that China could manipulate flows are hardly far-fetched.

SUMP is partly conceived as an answer. Its reservoir, with an estimated live storage of about 9.2 billion cubic metres, could give India some leverage over seasonal flows while generating clean power. It could also bolster energy security, reduce reliance on fossil fuels and lift an underdeveloped frontier state through jobs, infrastructure and royalties. These are serious arguments.

The human ledger, however, is heavy. The reservoir is feared to submerge 27 villages and affect dozens of other settlements. Opponents estimate one lakh to 1.5 lakh people could face displacement or disruption, figures that need testing through a transparent social impact assessment rather than acceptance as settled.

For the Adi, the Siang is far more than a water source. It runs through their identity, beliefs, farming traditions and collective memory. Ancestral land, burial grounds, community forests and paddy fields form a living inheritance that no cash package can replace. Relocation here risks unravelling customary institutions, social bonds, food systems and indigenous knowledge built over generations.

India’s record with large dams is a warning: compensation has often failed to restore livelihoods, leaving displaced communities struggling for years. The real question is not the size of the cheque but whether a community can genuinely be rebuilt elsewhere.

Fragile ground

The ecological stakes are equally grave. The Eastern Himalayas are among the planet’s most sensitive landscapes. Large reservoirs reshape river flows, sediment loads and aquatic habitats, affecting farming and fisheries downstream. The Siang valley also lies in a highly earthquake-prone zone, where a massive dam raises questions about seismic safety, slope stability and landslides.

Raising such concerns is not obstructionism. They demand independent geological, seismic and downstream impact studies, and an assessment of cumulative hydropower effects across the Brahmaputra basin, tributaries included. Assam has a direct stake: any change in the river’s flow, sediment or flood behaviour could touch the livelihoods of its 3.5 crore people.

Security is not a blank cheque

India’s unease about China controlling the headwaters of a shared river is justified. But a large dam does not automatically deliver control over the Brahmaputra or neutralise every upstream risk. How well the reservoir could buffer flows would depend on its operation, hydrology, the timing and volume of upstream releases and its physical limits. These questions need open scientific scrutiny.

National security matters, but it must not place decisions beyond public debate. Alienating residents of a vital border region could itself breed long-term instability. Frontier communities are not on the margins of India’s security; their trust and sense of belonging are part of its foundation.

The Arunachal government says the project is only at the pre-feasibility stage and no decision to build has been taken. Chief Minister Pema Khandu has said it will not proceed if experts find it technically unviable, and the state has promised impact assessments and community consultations should it advance. These assurances matter, but deep local mistrust suggests outreach has fallen short.

Permission for preliminary surveys is not informed consent, and peaceful dissent is not hostility to national progress. Equally, violence and vandalism have no place in legitimate protest; differences must be settled democratically and lawfully.

An independent consultative process involving community representatives, scientists, hydrologists, geologists and development experts could help establish the facts. All technical information should be shared in local languages so people understand what is proposed before anything irreversible is decided.

Development that carries consent

Development cannot be measured only in megawatts and investment figures. SUMP offers a chance to rethink how large projects are planned in ecologically fragile and culturally sensitive regions. If it proves viable, its costs must be weighed honestly against demonstrable benefits, with credible rehabilitation, protected livelihoods and due regard for Assam. If the environmental, geological or social costs prove unacceptable, the government must be ready to reconsider. Strategic ambition should not override scientific evidence.

The Siang is not merely a resource to be harnessed; it is the lifeline of communities whose history is bound up with it. India must protect its interests without making its citizens feel dispossessed in their ancestral homeland. The true test is not whether India can build a mega-dam, but whether it can reconcile strategic necessity with ecological responsibility and the rights of its indigenous people.

India cannot afford complacency upstream. Beijing has announced a giant hydropower scheme near the Great Bend of the Yarlung Tsangpo, reportedly of around 60,000 MW. With no comprehensive water-sharing treaty on the Brahmaputra, fears that China could manipulate flows are hardly far-fetched.

The writer is Deputy Director, Assam Information Centre, New Delhi; Views presented are personal.