A historic verdict on Rohingya genocide

 A historic verdict on Rohingya genocide
Published on: 

The ICJ’s landmark ruling holding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya is a historic victory for justice, but its enforcement remains uncertain

For nine years, Myanmar’s generals insisted that what happened in northern Rakhine in 2016-17 was counter-insurgency. On November 19, the International Court of Justice demolished that alibi. By nine votes to six, the world court ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya — the first time in its 80-year history that it has held a state responsible for committing the crime itself, not merely for failing to prevent it. The findings are unsparing. Security forces killed some 10,000 Rohingya, inflicted widespread sexual violence and “extreme violence against children”, and imposed measures to prevent births. Villages were razed and resettled by non-Rohingya; senior officials cast the community as subhuman. Genocidal intent, the court held, was “the only reasonable inference”, rejecting the army’s counter-terrorism defence outright. The Court in its verdict clearly states that Myanmar must halt violations, prosecute the guilty, guarantee non-repetition and make restitution: safe, voluntary and dignified return, restored property, a search for the disappeared, rehabilitation for survivors.

Compensation will be fixed later, but most importantly, the ruling is final. But the big question does this verdict change anything on ground. The answer is yes and no. Nothing will change by itself, but the world’s pressure might mount on the Junta to correct its course. All these years, Rohingyas were relegated to the background as the world had other issues to tackle. The ICJ verdict, though, is not enforceable, but it sets a series of actions from various Governments to pressure the Junta to mend its ways.  The man who commanded the 2017 operations, Min Aung Hlaing, is now President, installed after tightly controlled elections. And Rakhine has changed hands: the Arakan Army controls most of the state and has itself subjected Rohingya to forced labour, detention and forced recruitment — as has the junta.

About 520,000 Rohingya remain inside Myanmar under severe restrictions; nearly 1.2 million languish in Cox’s Bazar, where aid cuts have shrunk food rations. Return, the judgment’s central remedy, is thus a far cry. Yet the verdict matters. It converts a contested narrative into settled law. It strips legitimacy from a regime hungry for recognition — Britain has already moved to expel Myanmar’s defence attaché. For India, it is a dilemma. New Delhi rolled out the red carpet when Min Aung Hlaing chose India for his first foreign visit as President, and its Kaladan corridor runs through Rakhine via Sittwe port. But India is also a party to the Genocide Convention, and roughly 40,000 Rohingya live here, many facing detention.

Deporting people to a state judicially found to have committed genocide against them would be bad for its reputation. India need not choose between interest and principle. It can quietly press Naypyidaw to comply, use its channels to the Arakan Army to protect Rohingya in Rakhine, halt deportations, and help fund Bangladesh’s camps. India must tread carefully; one misstep could cost it dearly.