Senior Superintendent of Police in Bagpat, JK Shahi, said that they had to registered a case against the then CB-CID, ASP Pankaj Kumar, CB-CID inspector Gaje Singh, the then Circle Officer Barot, Rafiq Ahmed and constable clerk, Ram Dutt Sharma, for making an unfair probe. According to the incident, four youths— Farooq, Farman, Shakir and Shahid were booked in connection with the buffalo theft case registered in Chandinagar police station in Bagpat about a year back. However, controversy arises when the then CO of Barot, Rafiq Ahmed during his finding in the case, termed that no such incident took place hence a fake report has been registered by the complainant regarding buffalo theft. He also said that all the four named in the case were innoncent and that they the report against them should be expunged.