

CPI (M) leader Su Venkatesan’s recent comments on judicial duties, on Monday, drew the ire of Madras High Court judge Justice GR Swaminathan, who flayed the Communist leader for trying to lecture him on his responsibilities and remarked that the Madurai Lok Sabha MP travelled in a Benz car.
The sharp observations were made during an open court hearing on a contempt petition related to alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries across Tamil Nadu.
The war of words began after Justice Swaminathan, speaking at a recent book launch event, commented on the alleged fraudulent book procurement for the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore and suggested in a lighter vein that spiritual books on the late Kanchi Shankaracharya ought to be placed on the empty shelves (since the controversial books were withdrawn) as an “atonement” for the wrongdoing.
Reacting to the comment, Venkatesan on Sunday criticised the judge, arguing that library procurement fraud was a crime of corruption that must be punished by law.
The CPI (M) leader stated that punishing corruption is the duty of a judge, whereas prescribing atonement for sins is the job of astrologers.
On Monday, during a contempt hearing regarding the library book procurement scam, Justice Swaminathan clarified that his earlier remark about placing spiritual books in the library was strictly meant as a joke.
He turned his attention to Venkatesan’s criticism, recounting a chance encounter with the MP at the Chennai railway station about six months ago, prior to boarding the Pandian Express to Madurai.
Venkatesan arrived at the station in a high-end Mercedes-Benz car wearing branded attire and shoes, which initially led him to mistake the MP for a corporate executive, the judge said.
“He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything, and I don’t know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle,” Justice Swaminathan remarked.
Recalling their brief conversation while walking toward the train, the judge noted that while Venkatesan traveled in First AC, he routinely travelled in Sleeper Class.
“He said, ‘Sir, Judge sir, where are you going?’ I replied, ‘I normally travel by Sleeper Class. My number is S3-23,’” Justice Swaminathan recounted, adding, “So... he is telling me as to what I should do as a judge.”