Supreme Court judge Justice Vikram Nath on Monday said that eligibility, and not personal identity, must be the sole criterion for selection, stressing that fairness and merit should guide both judicial proceedings and recruitment. Addressing a function after unveiling a statue of Swami Vivekananda and inaugurating Aditya Patanjali Yogpeetham at the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission (UPPSC) premises here, Justice Nath said influence and power had no place in court proceedings, where evidence and arguments must prevail.
“Eligibility, and not personal identity, must be the sole criterion for selection. Fairness and merit should guide both judicial proceedings and recruitment. Just as influence or power does not speak in court, but evidence and reasoning do, recruitment must be based on eligibility, not favour or identity,” he said, according to an official statement.
Justice Nath said Articles 315 to 323 of the Constitution provide comprehensive safeguards to enable public service commissions to discharge their responsibilities with complete impartiality. Public service commissions do not merely conduct examinations but select outstanding civil servants to shape the country’s future, he said, adding that every appointment could have far-reaching consequences for governance in the decades ahead.
UPPSC Chairman Sanjay Sinha, speaking on the relationship between the judiciary and selection bodies, said their areas of responsibility might differ, but both shared the same statutory spirit, with public trust at their core.