

The appointment of Ashok Sampatrao Thorat as Director of Maharashtra Employees’ State Insurance Society (MH-ESIS) has triggered controversy, with social activist Anjali Damania questioning the State Government over the decision. She has sought transparency regarding his appointment, citing allegations linked to three separate cases involving Nashik, Beed and Kej.
Dr Thorat has faced allegations in connection with an alleged Rs 3.37 crore COVID-19 ICU procurement scam in Nashik, financial irregularities at Beed District Hospital during the pandemic, and an abortion-related case involving a minor in Kej, Beed district.
In March 2025, then Health Minister Prakash Abitkar announced Thorat’s suspension in the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly over alleged irregularities in Beed. However, reports indicate that his suspension was revoked in September 2025, following which he was deputed to the State Employees’ Insurance Society.
His subsequent appointment as Director has raised questions about the departmental inquiry, the grounds for revoking his suspension and the eligibility criteria applied during the appointment process.
In the Nashik COVID-19 ICU case, alleged financial irregularities of approximately Rs 3.37 crore were reported in contracts for modular ICU facilities at Nashik District Hospital and Malegaon General Hospital. An FIR was reportedly registered against eight individuals in October 2025, with Thorat’s name also featuring in media reports. The allegations remain subject to investigation.
The Beed case concerns alleged irregularities in the procurement of medicines and medical equipment during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Government is yet to publicly clarify the complete findings of the departmental proceedings and the reasons behind the revocation of his suspension.
In the Kej case, allegations concerned the handling of a medical procedure involving the termination of a 14-week pregnancy of a minor sexual assault victim. Questions were reportedly raised about the handling of information and potential DNA evidence. The final legal outcome and Thorat’s precise responsibility require verification through official court records. In a post on X, Damania questioned how an officer facing allegations in multiple cases could be appointed to an important administrative position while other accused persons were reportedly facing legal action.
She questioned Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis over the decision and demanded that the government make the appointment criteria public.
Damania has called for an immediate high-level, time-bound inquiry into all three cases, the circumstances surrounding the revocation of Dr Thorat’s suspension and the procedure followed for his appointment. She has also demanded appropriate legal action if wrongdoing is established.
Meanwhile, MLA Namita Mundada has also reportedly raised concerns regarding complaints against Thorat and the administrative action taken.
The Government is now facing questions over the transparency of the appointment process, the status of pending investigations and the reasons for assigning Dr. Thorat an important position involving administrative and financial responsibilities.
While allegations do not establish guilt, the controversy has intensified demands for an official explanation and disclosure of relevant government orders and inquiry findings.