IDBI Bank-Fairfax deal valuations: Separating facts from fiction

IDBI Bank-Fairfax deal valuations: Separating facts from fiction
Published on: 

Author: Madhav Nair | CA Sumeet Mehta

On 14th October, 2026, the Government of India approved the sale of 60.72 per cent (Government’s own 30.48 per cent and LIC’s 30.24 per cent) stake in IDBI Bank to Fairfax Financial Holdings for Rs 52,878 crores.

This is the largest foreign investment in the country’s banking sector. This is the culmination of the 9-year arduous journey of finally converting a development banking behemoth turned bureaucratic commercial bank into a professionally managed banking corporation. The process that started in May 2017 has finally reached its desired destination after facing multiple challenges of regulatory front, shortlisting “fit and proper” bidders, facing rejection from “fit and proper” bidders on the pricing, and then finally closing the deal at the best possible pricing that was win - win for both the parties.  

India’s debate on the proposed divestiture of IDBI Bank needs to move beyond the arguments of undervaluation and perceptions of being sold very cheaply. This concern rightfully deserves scrutiny, but they should not negate the facts to further some perceived fictional beliefs.

The IDBI - Fairfax transaction represents a progressive step towards building a stronger, more competitive, and professionally managed financial institution. It should be judged on its long-term value creation potential rather than through an ideological lens.

Financial turnaround is commendable

IDBI Bank has an important legacy in India’s economic development. Established in 1964 as a Development Financial Institution, it played a significant role in financing industrial growth. Its transformation into a commercial bank in 2004, however, brought considerable challenges, including mounting stressed assets, financial losses and repeated capital support from the Government and subsequently LIC.

Its placement under the RBI’s Prompt Corrective Action framework in May 2017 reflected the seriousness of these challenges. The subsequent turnaround has been commendable. Following improvements in its financial position, the restrictions were lifted in March 2021.

In FY2025-26, IDBI Bank reported a net profit of Rs 9,513 crore, deposits of Rs 3.47 lakh crore, advances of Rs 2.54 lakh crore and a capital adequacy ratio of 26.65 per cent. Gross NPAs declined to 2.32 per cent, while net NPAs stood at 0.15 per cent.

Need for sustainable growth amid globally transforming environment

These achievements deserve recognition. However, the real challenge is to convert this financial recovery into a sustainable, competitive and future-ready institution. A return to profitability should be the foundation for the next phase of growth, not the culmination of its transformation.

Valuation: A debate that must be evidence-based

Concerns have been raised about the valuation and the subsequent revision in the reserve price. Given the public interest involved, these questions deserve transparency and objective examination.

However, it is important to distinguish between an initial reserve price and the fair value established through an independent valuation exercise.

According to the Finance Ministry, two independent valuation agencies used market-multiple and asset-valuation methodologies to arrive at an average benchmark of Rs 75.99 per share. Fairfax’s successful offer of Rs 81 per share was above this benchmark and the individual estimates of both agencies. The consideration of approximately Rs 52,878 crore for the 60.72 per cent stake is substantial.

Valuation is a perspective; Price is the reality

There can always be differences of opinion on valuation assumptions and methodologies. What matters is whether the process was competitive, independently assessed, appropriately authorised and capable of protecting public value. Here, it is imperative to note that the previous round of bidding failed only due to disagreement over valuation wherein both the bidders — Fairfax and ENBD — refused to accept the reserve price of Rs 94.42 per share and both bid for a lower price. Finally independent valuers were roped up once again as reality dawned that the perceived value of the company was way higher than what the market was ready to pay. That’s when a revised valuation of Rs 75.99 per share was arrived. Here the concerns of managing a government-owned behemoth into a privately owned agile and competitive financial institution amidst rapidly rising competition in the market would have been at the front of the mind. The cost and challenges of transformation would have deterred many large potential financial institutions from bidding, which Fairfax and NBD were ready for. This has to be considered by everyone evaluating the deal.

PSU discount on valuations is a reality

A huge part of the controversy around valuations is claims that IDBI is sold at a lower value. This is evident from the table presented herewith that shows that the country’s largest bank — the State Bank of India (SBI) trades at a discount over relatively smaller private sector leaders like HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. While SBI trades at a TTM P/E Ratio of 11.31x and P/B Ratio of 1.81x, its private sector peers like HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank trade at a TTM P/E Ratio of 15.72x and 19.54x respectively and P/B Ratio of 2.19x and 3.31x respectively. Even a much smaller Kotak Mahindra Bank and Axis Bank trade at TTM P/E Ratio of 22.98x and 14.27x and P/B Ratio of 3.55x and 2.03x respectively, which is again much higher than SBI.

Even IDBI Bank trades at a TTM P/E Ratio and P/B Ratio of 10.2x and 1.22x respectively, which is way lesser than its equivalent similar range private sector peers like Federal Bank, AU Small Finance Bank, and IDFC First Bank. To go a step ahead, even the largest bank of the country — SBI — trades at a discount over the significantly smaller private sector

peers like Karur Vysya Bank, Bandhan Bank, and City Union Bank.

The reason for this undervaluation of Public Sector Banks vis-a-vis their Private Sector peers is the general perception of the governance standards and the management quality of PSU Banks in the minds of the larger investor community. Any legitimate procedural concerns on valuations must be addressed. However, disagreement over valuation methodology should not automatically translate into allegations of undervaluation or impropriety. The transaction must be judged on evidence, not insinuation.

Madhav Nair is a Senior Banker, CA Sumeet Mehta is a Corporate Finance professional and author of the book: Diagnosing GST for Doctors; Views presented are personal.