

The Agnipath (Agniveer) Scheme, launched in June 2022 to modernise India’s armed forces and curb rising pension bills, faced intense backlash that led to its partial rollback a few days ago.
While the Government initially defended the 4-year short-term recruitment model, persistent operational concerns, youth discontent, and political pressure forced significant structural revisions just as the first batch neared the end of its tenure.
Well, 25% of the Agniveers were made regular, and the remaining 75% have been asked to continue for two more years. After 2 years, most of the willing Agniveers will be retained, provided they meet the “standards”. What per cent would be retained has not been committed. Whether all the retained get a pension has also not been revealed. If all of them are retained and given a pension, then what is the difference between the earlier recruitment system and this one? And if not, is this another HR blunder like the one related to SS officers?
In the first place, there is no logic in letting anyone go in four or six years, the reason being the experience they have gained. In Op Sindhoor, the Agniveers did a fabulous job and were used to shoot down drones, lay mines and perform various other combat tasks. For the first time, they also gained experience in joint arms combat operations. Now, if these soldiers are let go, would they fire anti-drone guns in the civil street? Would they lay mines? Obviously not.
Op Sindoor has not been called off yet, and these soldiers are priceless as far as National Security is concerned, so letting them go is not an option at all. Also, giving them a pension is a small price to pay for skilled manpower at its prime.
There have been various arguments that have been put forward to justify the Agniveer Scheme; one of them is to channelise youth. They claim the youth could have gone into drugs and thus the scheme is a lifeline for them. This is factually flawed, since the selection process for Agniveers is very tough and physically demanding; no astray youth/ potential astray would get selected anyway.
Having said that, the new proposal is more balanced.
Two-Year Service Extension. While the top 25% of Agniveers still transition directly into regular service after four years on merit, the remaining 75% are now offered an optional second engagement of two years.
Pathway to Permanent Absorption. After completing six years of total service, all willing Agniveers who meet prescribed medical and performance criteria will be absorbed into the regular cadre.
A detailed statement about pension would actually close all uncertainty.
After this rollback, we should look into the option of getting back the Gurkha Soldiers also. Their employment in the Indian Army has strategic connotations. It binds Nepal closer to India, particularly their Gen Z.
Conclusion
The policies related to the Armed Forces must be planned with due diligence. Partial rollback or repeated modifications don’t send the right signal to the youth of the country and to the soldiers.
The November 4 revision is a welcome course correction, but only half a reform. It came weeks before around 18,300 Agniveers were due to exit, suggesting the Government reacted to a looming crisis rather than planned for it.
Two gaps need closing. The Defence Ministry must notify what share of the remaining 75% will be absorbed, and on what criteria. It must also state plainly whether those absorbed will earn a pension. Until then, uncertainty is merely deferred by two years. The revision also opens a diplomatic door.
Nepal froze Gurkha recruitment in 2022 precisely over the four-year tenure and the soldiers’ fate after it. New Delhi should use the new pathway to restart that intake.
Armed forces policy demands due diligence. Repeated mid-course corrections send the wrong signal to young aspirants and soldiers already in uniform. A soldier unsure of tomorrow cannot fully commit to today’s fight.
The writer is a defence analyst and writes extensively on geopolitics and strategic affairs; Views presented are personal.