The Lok Sabha on Wednesday approved a bill to revamp the functioning of the Institutes of Chartered Accountants, Cost Accountants and Company Secretaries, with Finance and Corporate Affairs Minister Nirmala Sitharaman asserting that the changes will not impact the autonomy of these bodies. The Chartered Accountants, Cost and Works Accountants and Company Secretaries (Amendment) Bill seeks to appoint non-Chartered Accountant (CA), non-cost accountant and non-company secretary as the presiding officer of the disciplinary committees of the Institutes.
Piloting the bill, the Minister said the amendments will not infringe upon the autonomy of the three Institutes. Instead, it will enhance the quality of audit and improve the country's investment climate, she added. The amendments, she said, "will make the institutes more responsible and accountable" and encourage them to adopt global best practices. All stakeholders should have greater confidence of audit statements, she said.
Many Opposition MPs including Vishnu Prasad (Congress) and NK Premachandran (RSP) said that the appointing MCA officials in the disciplinary boards will hamper the autonomy of these Institutes. Among other things, the bill provides for setting up of a coordination committee headed by the Secretary of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. It will have representations from the three institutes.
The Minister said that earlier, the three institutes had signed an MoU to set up a coordination committee but the proposal could not take off. The committee would help in managing the resources of the institutes, she said, adding that IIMs and IITs too have coordination committees. The bill also provides for registration of firms with the institutes and it will help in paving the way for Indian accountancy firms to grow big, she said. It also proposes to enhance the quantum of fines for partners and firms found guilty of misconduct.
Responding to criticism that the amendments would dilute the autonomy of the institutes, Sitharaman said, "there is no proposal or intention to impinge upon the autonomy of the three institutes... They will continue to perform their functions." Participating in the debate, Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said that while the Minister referred to the US, UK, South Africa in her reply, the bill failed to abide by their best practices.
"Through this bill, the government is making a subtle and deliberate attempt to consolidate power and to snatch away the independence of institutions by dismantling the autonomous framework of the concerned institutions," he said. TMC member Saugata Roy asked the Minister what specific steps her Ministry had taken to prevent corruption by chartered accountants.
NCP leader Supriya Sule said that her main concern was about the autonomy of the three accountancy institutes. "You gave the examples of IITs and IIMs. But these institutes are funded by the government while the these are not. How can they be compared? Doesn't this take away the autonomy of these institutions?," she asked.
